Wednesday, February 22, 2023

Is That Dress White And Gold Or Blue And Black? The New York Times

black and blue dress or white and gold

In addition, he says that discussions of this stimulus are not frivolous, as the stimulus is both of interest to science and a paradigmatic case of how different people can sincerely see the world differently. The philosopher Barry C. Smith compared the phenomenon with Ludwig Wittgenstein and the rabbit–duck illusion, although the rabbit-duck illusion is an ambiguous image where, for most people, the alternative perceptions switch very easily. This appears to be exactly what may be happening in the case of the famous color ambiguous dress!

black and blue dress or white and gold

I learned back in my Amiga-using, pixel-editing days that there's a lot of blue in most metallics. I don't know if that's an artifact of what happens to light when it bounces off of them, or what, sorry. But I know that if you're trying to make something look metallic, you're going to be adding some blue to it. Looks absolutely, positively white/pale gold to me. And that was on three screens with a photographer's eye. Buzzfeed's online story about the dress has been shared more than 20 million times.

Why do I see blue and gold on the dress?

For the situations where different people are looking at the same screen or printed photograph, my guess is that the variability comes from the color/brightness/etc sensitivity of their eyes. For example, in my own eyes, one of them sees the wall in a brighter shade of white than the other eye. Perhaps those who aren't as sensitive to blue might see the blue/white part of the dress as a shade of white, and call it white.

After all, when you walk outside during the day, every inch of space around you is filled with photons—but it’s not like you see any of them. The fact that some people see it differently shouldn't be any more surprising than the fact that some people are colorblind or the fact that our senses can be fooled by optical illusions. Limitations of this study include the relatively small number of subjects tested. A larger sample size may provide more definitive evidence for macular pigment and VEP differences. While our results add to the growing body of knowledge regarding perception of the Dress and offer factors which may predispose observers to see WG vs. BB, we offer no definitive basis for the dichotomy in perception. But morning larks were more likely to think the dress was backlit and in shadow, and 80 per cent of the early risers in the survey saw it as white and gold.

Singer Kesha suffers vocal cord hemorrhage, shares post on Instagram with fans

These areas are thought to be critical in high cognition activities such as top-down modulation in visual perception. Similar theories have been expounded by the University of Liverpool's Paul Knox, who stated that what the brain interprets as colour may be affected by the device the photograph is viewed on, or the viewer's own expectations. Anya Hurlbert and collaborators also considered the problem from the perspective of colour perception. They attributed the differences in perception to individual perception of colour constancy. That's what Twitter user Arthur asked his followers, and people are literally arguing over the answer. The brand confirmed that the sandals are blue and dark blue, but that hasn't stopped the internet from debating.

In the days after “The Dress” was posted online, a group led by psychologist Karl Gegenfurtner at Giessen University in Germany asked 15 people to view the photograph on a well-calibrated color screen under controlled lighting. The participants then had to adjust the color of a disc to correspond to the colors they saw in the photograph. For the lighter stripe, participants reported seeing a continuous range of shades from light blue to dark blue, rather than white and blue, the two dominant colors reported so far. If on a apple product- (iphone,ipad,ipod.) You can invert the colors. When this happens while having the dress on you screen it will be pure white and gold when you turn it off its blue and black. Personally I think that this debate has gone way to far, its just a dress.

Most viewed

The illumination can change dramatically depending on the time of day, or between incandescent and fluorescent lighting. Yet in spite of this, the brain almost always identifies an object's true color correctly. But to husband Kanye West, it was solidly black and blue.

If you don't get the confirmation within 10 minutes, please check your spam folder. However, experts agree that the only individuals who can accurately identify “the dress” are those who see it in person. Zenia is a young musician, actress, natural health advocate and activist supporting movements, foundations and people who want to inform to transform the world in a positive way. She aims to help people live from their heart through the power of music, art, lifestyle changes and awareness. Her family lineage is Yoga, Meditation, Holistic Health, Education and Law. "Everyone went to DEFCON 5 immediately when someone disagreed. It was like you were questioning something even more fundamental than their religion," Wired articles editor Adam Rogers said.

However, there's still a human perception factor going on. I had looked at the picture on my laptop, and it was clearly white and gold. Then later I pulled the exact same picture up on my iPhone to show it to someone, and it looked black and blue. I then concluded that the picture looked different on my laptop than my phone due to differences in the display. When I got back home I pulled the picture up on both my phone and laptop to do a direct comparison, and both, including on my phone, looked white and gold again. But they can perceived as either blue and black or white and gold.

black and blue dress or white and gold

Dr. Reega Garg, an ophthalmologist at Mt. Sinai, said we're highly sensitive to the color blue and the cells in our eyes cause people to interpret the picture differently. She adds the black stripe can also throw off the color. Optometry experts are calling the photo a one-in-a-million shot that perfectly captures how people's brains perceive color and contrast in dramatically different ways.

No comments:

Post a Comment